site image

    • Tailscale vs zerotier reddit. Check mode is only available for Tailscale SSH connections.

  • Tailscale vs zerotier reddit Hi, I'm using tailscale and not new to mesh VPN nor wireguard. The docs are lacking and the config file isn't exactly easy to see what's Selfhosted Netbird is simple and complete, with webmanager but Headscale not. However, Tailscale’s encryption is based on the WireGuard protocol, which is considered to be more secure and efficient than ZeroTier’s use of the Internet Protocol Security (IPsec) protocol. Used to do openVPN but tailscale setup is way simpler. Fully self hosted, easy meshing and wireguard kernel speeds. com Sep 19, 2023 · Both Tailscale and ZeroTier use end-to-end encryption to secure network traffic between devices. All of the reading I have done on this site points to using ZeroTier or Tailscale. 168. Nice yeah, most Tailscale users I talk to are using it for home or very narrow/small use cases. Sure, port forwarding has less delay but tailscale is easier. I've been pondering on going with either Cloudflair Tunnel (requires a domian name) vs Tailscale/ZeroTier for remote access when I'm not at my house. Not to mention the problem user space app ge Hi Everyone, we're looking at replacing our current VPN setup (L2TP over IPSec) with something that supports 2fa and is cross-platform. Thank you dude probably doesn't understand networking well enough to know that nord can't/doesn't provide what you need. What happens when you step up from a home lab? You get a home datacenter! For those of us who host… Tailsclae is peer to peer with relay servers as fallback when peer to peer cant be established. Zerotier does not. Apr 3, 2024 · Tailscale. Tailscale is using BSD3, a proper open source license. in effect what youre getting is a mesh overlay network, or in other words point to point encrypted tunnels between any two of your devices. My concern is that a compromise of their control plane would allow someone to add devices to your network. Protocol ‍Tailscale uses a userspace WireGuard protocol for its clients, while ZeroTier uses their own in-house protocol. To me, the differences seem too small to matter for casual and power users, so I say choose the one that's easiest to deploy. After a whole weekend of reading up on stuff, I’ve successfully replaced it with Tailscale. Their firewall rules are User-Based. Tried Tailscale and Zerotier, there was a problem on some devices when switching from wifi to internet which was breaking internet access, switched to Wireguard and now i'm happy. I use twingate for secure access to Azure resources. I tested Tailscale and got 80-100MS Ping; whereas with Ngrok I got 90-240ms. Dec 12, 2020 · After research, I have determined that the ISP currently does not offer IPv6. Apr 3, 2024 · Support Remote access: ZeroTier vs Tailscale vs Cloudflare vs NPM (self. You want a mesh VPN but want easier discovery and key distribution? Try ZeroTier, Tailscale, etc. Tailscale does support DNS on it's clients and is easy to manage. 0 Release). I've got a Tailscale subnet router dropped into it's own subnet that's firewalled off. My main thing is (if I'm understanding this correctly) going with Cloudflare exposes HA to the public via HTTPS and anyone could hit it whereas it's the opposite for Tailscale. I would definitely be looking into zerotier or tailscale if i were you, i know tailscale lets me communicate with other protocols, don't see why games would be any different AFAIK you can't self-host Tailscale either, or at least not easily and not with interoperability with hosted Tailscale users. I was wondering if anyone has had experience with either and if there's anything you wish you knew before Tailscale uses the WireGuard protocol, but not the WireGuard C library (the kernel module). As much as I like TailScale I am not comfortable that I have to use google to sign in. This has a lot of restrictions like limited production use. If you don't, then whatever whatever. I will change my OpenVPN nodes(100+) and choose Netbird instead Tailscale(paid) or Zerotier(great selfhosted, but you need an external UI like zero-ui to manage your nodes and authorizations). Tailscale has no (only beta) possibility to control traffic between Servers. Teleport and TailScale are options, but I am leaning towards teleport because I can act on my network vs tailscale, I have to install multiple clients md harder to control what ports/services to access. WireGuard would be the same as Tailscale, because Tailscale is management layer on top of Wireguard. Netbird will have mobile clients soon. Then enable it in the web interface, and install on Steam Deck (dont forget the --accept-routes flag). However, free tier is limited to 25 nodes while Radmin network can have a maximum of 150 users. No port forwarding. Lanemu is an underrated alternative that is practically unlimited - by default you can create a network with up to 65534 peers. Everything is great, EXCEPT what I saw in the Tailscale SSH documentation: Check mode is optional and not enabled by default. Wireguard is a better VPN which aims to be as easy to configure and deploy as SSH. Once the Wireguard tunnels are established, Tailscale doesn't get involved (unless it can't bust through NAT and has to use a relay node) We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. The Twingate integrations to Okta, Jamf, Crowdstrike, terraform all look pretty solid. Please recommend me something good. Zerotier on the other hand has lacking features for Clients, as no DNS rerouting (Let's wait for the magical unicorn 2. By comparison, I did a performance test accessing SQL Server over twingate vs tailscale. pacman -S tailscale sudo systemctl enable --now tailscaled sudo tailscale up tailscale ip -4 -I needed this one to allow Tailscale to access my local network devices being shared by a device with Tailscale on my local network. Tailscale or Ngrok for hosting a Minecraft Java server? I cannot do port forwarding due to my router. com . That said I actually found Tailscale to be a bit more reliable where sometimes I couldn't connect at times with ZeroTier. This is where I need help. From what I understand so far, Twingate and Zerotier is not what I looked for; I do not want to install any sort of client to access my server. 0. Seems kind of also reflected in what Tailscale as a company is focused on (personal users), which is why Twingate seems to come up often in the Tailscale crowd. or. Dec 31, 2024 · Tailscale is just one of a hundred options for coordinated wireguard, IMO. I was able the tailscale connections reporting direct peer connections. ZeroTier is an easier alternative to VPN to create secure connections between any of your systems, without setting up servers, without even caring if the device doesn't have a static IP, DNS registration, etc. It does add a bit of latency (+20-50 ms) but it’s much better and easier to setup than ZeroTier or ngrok. Very safe: ZeroTrust setup, only selected clients can access. I looked into Zerotier and didn't find anything more appealing than Tailscale, especially after Tailscale added multiple subnet routers in the free tier. I use Tailscale or Zerotier in cases when I want to have a Mesh VPN and when no direct connection is possible in either direction, like when connecting two private networks. If you cannot forward a port in your home router, you can use Parsec, or things like Tailscale/Zerotier with Moonlight instead. Expected a lot due to its popularity. Zerotier is using the Business Source License which is not an open source license (does not support The Open Source Definition). Yeah, that's exactly what I'm saying - Nebula needs a manager to make deployment as simple as Zerotier or Tailscale (or Hamachi or. I then learn that I could do something similar to CF Zero Trust with Tailscale. And yes, care was taken that tailscale connected directly and not via relay. Tailscale for End User Client Access and Zerotier for Server-to-Server connections. If you don’t need it on a server I’d highly recommend checking out the essential mod as well https://essential. Setting a Wireguard server is a little bit more advanced, the good thing about it is that your network traffic does not have to go to a 3rd party middleman. I have used both. There is no autoconnect feature on zerotier android app. Tailscale covers all of the extra meshnet features. I’ve done many tests to compare OpenVPN and tailscale on the same NAS. they run a server that helps broker vpn connections between your nodes running their client. I'm running tailscale on my router and Android phones. This can all be surmised as being 'default-closed' rather than 'default-open'. Sure, but that's just the regular VPN, many options available there. ZeroTier is free to use if you have less than 50 devices, and Tailscale if you have less than 20. Tailscale's edge client is open source but they are (again AFAIK as I am not affiliated) more or less like GitHub-- a single SaaS endpoint. Feb 26, 2025 · Tailscale uses a more modern and safer VPN solution (IIRC Tailscale uses Wireguard and ZeroTeir uses OpenVPN). Which Is how zerotier functions as well, peer to peer with relay as backup. As for the internet hosting tool, it’s intended for gf experience. But it comes with flexibility and you can do a lot more in Zerotier than with Tailscale ACLs. Edit: forgot one giant caveat: tailscale mobile clients now allow you to use your own self hosted instance. You would have to compile your own android client so if you want to go fully self hosted AND use Android devices you can't go Zerotier. 2. Just to dial into your home network you don't need either, it's commonly called a "Roadwarrior" VPN setup and was a very common setup with openvpn even when Wireguard didn't exist yet. OpenVPN worked at near full speed up to 300Mbit on my test machine. The person connecting to the server is trusted. Handles SSL using TLS autogenerated certificates. Tailscale ACL vs ZeroTier network rules. The userspace module is an entirely different implementation (written in Go) is slower than the kernel module irrespective of whether it is used in the context of Tailscale or on its own. Battery life will take a hit. For me Netmaker was the perfect blend of all 3. Here's a comparison page from Tailscale: https://tailscale. However, I’m still getting some pretty bad slow downs and stutters, enough though my host is connected to Ethernet with 100mbps up. zerotier. I work on the project, here is a long comparison I wrote of OpenZiti vs Wireguard with some references to Tailscale. Tailscale is definitely easy to use, many vouch for that. Might still work with sunshine but for newbies i reccomend tailscale or zerotier 21K subscribers in the HomeDataCenter community. DM me and I'll send you a link to download a file off my server through the "public" side of my setup and you can judge the speed to my server yourself. It is only Layer3. Tailscale helps establish the tunnels using Wireguard between devices with a little bit of NAT busting. com/compare/zerotier/. 1, you need to adjust the command if it is elsewhere). Tailscale is also a secure VPN designed to quickly enable remote work, but with Tailscale, the connection is direct: Once Tailscale is installed on two devices, they can access each other over a secure connection, no matter where they are in the world — as long as they can access the public internet. Cons: Can't use a custom domain. Typically used if you have a server or router on a LAN enrolled into Tailscale and you want to be able to reach other devices on that LAN without installing Tailscale on each of them. You like Tailscale but want something faster that you could host yourself? Try Netmaker. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. homeassistant) submitted 1 month ago by Chaosblast I've been using HA remotely for a year using Nginx Proxy Manager, my own domain, and DDNS provided by my own router. If such a direct connection would be possible, i would probaly use just Wireguard. this means that you can route traffic between them as if they were on the same subnet (because they are, its just a virtual exactly no one said a dam thing on how to fix the issue. Zerotier and Tailscale are VPN options if you want to securely connect to sunshine without having to port forward. Check mode is only available for Tailscale SSH connections. While Tailscale has ACLs to implement restrictions, this is done from a network perspective rather than trying to explicitly not trust the network and weak network identifiers. Is this why people recommend the zerotier or tailscale vpns? Or do I not need to configure those if I’m able to connect to my pc without issue. sudo tailscale up --accept-routes Put tailscale on Raspberry Pi, but launch it with sudo tailscale up --advertise-routes=192. You like Tailscale but want to host it yourself? Try Headscale. . ZeroTier is open-source and supports Linux/macOS unlike Radmin. Unless you will be using the mesh part of Tailscale or Zerotier, to connect multiple networks, it has very little advantage over a regular VPN, i. e. Not saying the Nord offering is no good, but it's available already if you'd rather not use Nord. While they share some features, they each have unique strengths for different situations. It has been very solid and very fast. If I go with a regular Tailscale account, it seems like I should have better security as it's maintained by pros but at the potential cost of privacy since anyone at Tailscale could conceivably use that to access my data. Tailscale just creates a secure lan to anywhere you are. The Zerotier mobile clients have the Zerotier planets hardcoded in. Aug 1, 2023 · While ZeroTier and Tailscale are very similar, and can often be used to accomplish the same use cases, they do have some differences, both technical and non-technical, which could make the difference for some users. it will then work. So, that is not a security concern, but I would like to know security wise if Tailscale is worth it. So setup sunshine, port forward on your router and then connect with moonlight and you'll be good to go at home and remote. Wireguard is pretty easy if you have a public IP, but if you have any sort of NAT complexity, Tailscale is a blessing (and is Wireguard under the hood). None have ever gone through a server in the middle. I think zerotier did some cool things, and we only learned about it well after creating nebula. Tailscale (as managed SaaS) is a better comparison to CloudZiti. We do keep a much closer eye on our community discussion board over at https://discuss. You want to access region-locked web content without physically moving? Zerotier and Tailscale are VPN options if you want to securely connect to sunshine without having to port forward. ZeroTier is more complicated, both the ‘language’ and stateless nature of rules engine. , doesn't matter what the underlying tech is) because presently too many people are scared of having to do the config themselves. (it's a killer) The main reason I am using Tailscale and not Zerotier is the open source licenses they are using. via Wireguard. If you need L2 bridging, there's no replacing it with Tailscale or similar. The problem is depending on VPN implementation, it can prevent your phone from deep sleeping due to it trying to maintain the tunnel. I've tried straight wireguard, straight TailScale, TailScale + headscale and now use Netmaker for everything. I am looking for more options which provide similar VPN services. I do understand that Tailscale is built upon Wireguard, but I like the fact that ZeroTier has a zero-trust approach which allows me to manage any connections. You're locked to the random generated ones. One point of difference is that Tailscale uses Wireguard while ZT uses its own protocol. Really depends on what you're trying to do and how easy you need/want it to be and if it's worth the performance hit. 2 - I'm on the 200/200 plan. Tailscale + any VPN of your choice offers all of this. 0/24 (assuming here your router is at 192. We invite you to add your questions & posts over there where our team will see it much quicker! Aug 5, 2021 · Good comparison, thanks! I’m using both ZeroTier and Tailscale on daily basis so here is my two-penny worth. So I'd use that just based off of that. The reason I want to try tailscale is: 1 I have to reconnect the zerotier network each time I switch wifi/mobile network- somehow it doesn't switch automatically, just have to toggle the connect switch off/on. Tailscale was systematically 30% slower than OpenVPN, both at lower and higher upload speeds. ZeroTier is a bit different, it creates VPN L2 networks with some rather specialized firewalling features. Our self-hosted controllers are fully interoperable with the network. As far as best, I like simple. Actually, battery use from encryption with modern CPU and HW accelerated cipher is pretty negligible. Hi, I am looking for alternatives for ZeroTier and TailScale. Pros: Offers a domain by default. I have tailscale on about 20 devices and all of them make peer to peer connections with each other. Basically the same thing a commercial VPN service theyre just commercial vpn services. PISH Anyway on the PC (if you are using a PC which I think you are) goto to the talescale icon in your rightside pop up in windows on the taskbar find the PC IP and use that in your moonlight to find the computer. gg/en/ I set up Tailscale SSH, as it seems that everything that I want to do is handled with Tailscale ACLs. I've heard good things about both Tailscale and Zerotier, the SSO support for both is a big win, and the per user pricing is pretty reasonable for both. See full list on tailscale. Tldr; Anyone did a comparison between netmarker and netbird before? I couldn't find any info on reddit or elsewhere. Twingate was many times faster than tailscale. I started out with ZeroTier but unfortunately, it's become an issue. Exit nodes let you reach the internet from a Tailscale device using another Tailscale device as a forward proxy. All the pieces referenced aside from my actual server (Argo Tunnel, Tailscale, ZeroTier) have a free tier, and that's what I use. When we looked at it, there were a few reasons we probably wouldn't have used ZeroTier in production, even if we had found it before creating Nebula Outsourcing network availability. As much as we at ZeroTier love Reddit, we can't keep our eyes on here 24/7. Reply reply Tailscale uses the WireGuard protocol, but not the WireGuard C library (the kernel module). Sep 7, 2023 · Tailscale and ZeroTier are two widely-used tools that let you connect your devices safely over the internet, like creating a secret tunnel. Then I learned about Headscale that's been described as a LOCAL Tailscale coordinator. glnyoe vccefn harja igz wfqpgq uitbyd dyi tqpvnl duashh gtfxf